The sticky note that started the reset
In January 2024, I found a sticky note on my monitor: 'Can you add how to start a lanyard to the onboarding wiki?' That was it. No context. No urgency flag. Just a small, practical question from HR that had somehow become my problem.
I am the office administrator for a 400-person company. I manage ordering—roughly $180,000 annually across 12 vendors—and I report to both operations and finance. When I took over purchasing in 2020, I thought my job was to get the lowest price and move on. That was wrong, or at least incomplete.
We had three supply closets, about 140 SKUs, and no shared definition of 'standard.' People ordered what they liked. Finance saw duplicate invoices. I saw a closet full of almost-right refills. The most frustrating part: the same complaint kept showing up—pen bodies that looked alike but did not take the same refill. You would think a catalog would prevent that. It did not.
The consolidation project
The 2024 vendor consolidation project gave me cover. Finance wanted fewer vendors. Operations wanted fewer tickets. I wanted fewer messages asking where the good pens were. I assumed the answer was bulk buying. I was half right.
First, I surveyed the people who actually used the stuff. Not a giant survey—about 60 responses and a few hallway conversations. Facilities and field techs wanted a mechanical pencil that could take a beating and advance with one hand. Front desk and admin wanted gel pens that did not skip on sign-in sheets. Our EU-facing team needed A4 paper, clearly labeled, not hidden behind letter-size reams. HR wanted lanyards for badge access and a better onboarding page. None of that was exotic. The problem was that our catalog made people guess.
So we built three kits instead of one. For the facilities and field kit, we added the Pentel Quicker Clicker mechanical pencil. The side-click advance was the reason—people taking notes while standing or holding a clipboard did not have to reposition the pencil. For admin and front desk, we standardized on Pentel Energel bodies and listed the Pentel Energel needle tip refill as the approved refill. I made the compatibility note very clear: check the body model before reordering. We also kept A4 paper in the EU kit and letter paper in the US kit, with different labels and bin locations. Small thing. Big reduction in wrong orders.
The pilot that did not work
Then I made the classic mistake. I tried to force one pen and one pencil across the whole company. 'Simpler,' I told myself. 'Fewer SKUs.' The pilot with 60 people lasted about six weeks. People hated it. Not because the products were bad—they were not—but because I had confused standardization with uniformity. The field team did not need the front-desk pen. The front desk did not need the field pencil. And the people who lost their favorite writing tool started hoarding the old stock in their desks. I found a drawer with 37 assorted pens in it. Not ideal.
When I compared the pilot results side by side—same training, same catalog, different teams—I finally understood why the first rollout stalled. The issue was not product choice. It was decision design. We had removed bad options but had not given people a clear path to the right option. That is when I stopped calling it a supply catalog and started calling it a buying guide.
It took me about 18 months and maybe 140 orders to understand that vendor consolidation is not really a price exercise. It is an education exercise. If people do not know why the Pentel Quicker Clicker mechanical pencil is in the field kit, or why the Pentel Energel needle tip refill only goes with certain bodies, they will default to what they already know. An informed customer asks better questions and makes faster decisions. I would rather spend 10 minutes explaining options than deal with mismatched expectations later.
What changed
We relaunched with a simple punch-out catalog and an internal one-pager for each kit. The catalog had photos, compatibility notes, and a 'if you are not sure, ask' link. We also cut vendors from 12 to 7 and SKUs from about 140 to 45—maybe 48, I would have to check the system. Ordering time dropped from roughly 45 minutes a week to about 15. Mis-order tickets went down enough that finance stopped asking me about duplicate invoices. I want to say it was a 40% drop, but do not quote me on that. The bigger win was quieter: fewer where-do-I-find-this emails.
The onboarding page turned out to be part of the same problem. HR had asked for a simple how to start a lanyard note because new hires were staring at badge straps like they were a puzzle. I added a photo series and a three-line explanation. While I was in there, I linked the benefits resources HR wanted, including a dog age calculator. Not procurement. Not strategic. But people used the page. The two most-clicked links for a while were the lanyard instructions and the dog age calculator. That taught me something: people will read a clear page if it answers a real question, even a small one.
I also had to tighten our sustainability language. We had vendors sending eco and recyclable claims on packaging and paper. Per the FTC Green Guides (ftc.gov/green-guides), environmental claims like recyclable should be substantiated, so I stopped repeating them in internal descriptions unless the vendor could back them up. That was not glamorous, but it kept our buying guide accurate. Accuracy matters more than a nice-sounding label.
What I would do differently
Start with the questions people actually ask. Not the SKUs you want to sell them, and not the spreadsheet finance wants to see. The questions. Will this refill fit my pen? Where is the A4 paper? How do I start this lanyard? Boring questions, mostly. But boring questions are where the waste lives.
Also, separate the spine from the preferences. Standardize the stuff that causes compatibility problems—refills, paper sizes, badge accessories, toner. Leave room for a few human preferences. We kept two approved pen bodies and one mechanical pencil line in the core kit. That was enough. We did not need 14 kinds of black ink.
Bottom line: if you are the person who owns office ordering, you are not just buying supplies. You are teaching a small, recurring class on how to choose them. Do that well, and the catalog gets shorter, the invoices get cleaner, and the sticky notes slow down. A little.
Discuss this article with a workspace planner